By
By
Webinar Library
Best of ESM Methodology and Skills

What’s the Evidence? How to Probe Documents Beyond the Obvious

Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
Jun 23, 2023
2.2K views
Advanced
CC
Want to watch the full webinar?
Join now to access all 2,100 webinars and unlock all features.
Join now
Syllabus
Chat Log
Join now

Content

Play. Playing.
Welcome
2m 00s
Play. Playing.
Class Overview
1m 27s
Play. Playing.
Introduction
9m 14s
Play. Playing.
John Watts
15m 37s
Play. Playing.
Captain Walton
4m 58s
Play. Playing.
Back to John
1m 58s
Play. Playing.
Strategies
14m 36s
Play. Playing.
What's the Evidence?
13m 45s
Play. Playing.
Announcements / prizes
2m 33s
Play. Playing.
Questions / answers
11m 44s

About this webinar

Whatever our research dilemma, a correct solution depends upon a reliable evaluation of the evidence we are using. Evidence is not concrete. It is not definitive. It is not a source. It is not a fact. It is not “proof.” It is, instead, our interpretation of what a piece of information means. Evidence is both singular and collective. We analyze it piece by piece. We correlate each piece with everything else discoverable, and then we analyze the whole to reach conclusions that are reliable. This session walks us through the three levels at which each piece of information should be evaluated, in order to draw a reliable conclusion from it. The principles are then illustrated with a common but thorny problem: a Revolutionary War–era case study that might be called: How to Identify Someone Who’s Been Mangled by ‘Facts.’

*** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***

About the speaker

About the speaker

Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
Across a long career, Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL, FASG, FUGA, FNGS, has been an innovator of research methods and strategies. Published widely by academic and popular presses, she edited a national-level scholarly journal for 16 years, taught
Learn more...

Comments (111)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

1000 characters remaining
Cancel Submit

Sort by Newest
Sort by Close.
  • Newest
  • Oldest
  • Likes
  1. HH
    Harold Harrison
    5 months ago

    Thank You. Now I realize just how much I don’t know.

    Reply
  2. ED
    Elaine Drury
    5 months ago

    Thank you for sharing your knowledge, it was great

    Reply
  3. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    5 months ago

    Wonderful presentation as usual.

    Reply
  4. BM
    Barbara McGeachy
    5 months ago

    What an amazing researcher! She is the highest level of thoroughness and accuracy. Inspiriational!

    Reply
  5. MB
    Margaret Balcom
    5 months ago

    Any Elizabeth Shown Mills webinar is 5 star!! Thank you for sharing your wisdom!!

    Reply
  6. DZ
    Della Zane
    5 months ago

    I love what I’m learning through the ESM webinars. She amazes me every time. Mind blown!

    Reply
  7. TD
    Teresa Dunlap
    5 months ago

    Demonstrated the ease of getting same name people confused.

    Reply
  8. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    5 months ago

    Another amazing webinar! So grateful to have this experience of listening and learning from Elizabeth.

    Reply
Show all comments

Related Webinars

Advanced
1:17:07
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Dissection & Analysis of Research Problems: 10 Steps to a Solution
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.7K views
CC
Dissection & Analysis of Research Problems: 10 Steps to a Solution
Solutions to tough problems are not just “found.” They are analytically constructed. This session explains how to break down problems into their most-critical elements. It summarizes the types of questions and tests that should be applied to each. Then it demonstrates how to analyze, rank, and assemble the resulting answers into an effective research plan. In this process you’ll walk through ten steps, learning how to apply micro and macro analysis, evaluate prior conclusions, argue with their evidence, develop targeted worksheets, and complete a plan of action that can be pursued as time permits. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Dissection & Analysis of Research Problems: 10 Steps to a Solution
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.7K views
Solutions to tough problems are not just “found.” They are analytically constructed. This session explains how to break down problems into their most-critical elements. It summarizes the types of questions and tests that should be applied to each. Then it demonstrates how to analyze, rank, and assemble the resulting answers into an effective research plan. In this process you’ll walk through ten steps, learning how to apply micro and macro analysis, evaluate prior conclusions, argue with their evidence, develop targeted worksheets, and complete a plan of action that can be pursued as time permits. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Fri, October 27 2023: 18:00 UTC
Login to register (for webinar members)
Login to register (for webinar members)
Advanced
1:14:30
Places and EthnicitiesBest of ESMMethodology and SkillsWebtember
Using Negative Evidence: The Power of Silence in the Records
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
2.3K views
CC
Using Negative Evidence: The Power of Silence in the Records
Can genealogists take a negative (the absence of something) and develop it into a positive (proof of something)? Yes! If we understand what we’re working with and how to develop it. Negative evidence is a tool used by many investigative fields; but its definition varies between disciplines. This session defines the concept used by genealogists and historians: contextually suggestive silence. In layman’s language, Mills clearly separates negative evidence from concepts that are often confused with it: negative searches, negative findings, negative arguments, and negative conclusions. Case studies using autosomal and Y-DNA, censuses, church records, death certificates, land deeds and grants, topo maps, and other source types to demonstrate how to recognize contextually suggestive silence and develop it into solutions for situations in which no document explicitly answers our research question. *** This class requires a password and an active webinar membership to attend. On the day of the webinar, obtain the password (located at the top of FamilyTreeWebinars.com when logged in as a member). Then click the Join Webinar link in your confirmation/reminder email, and enter the password when prompted. ***
Places and EthnicitiesBest of ESMMethodology and SkillsWebtember
Using Negative Evidence: The Power of Silence in the Records
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
2.3K views
Can genealogists take a negative (the absence of something) and develop it into a positive (proof of something)? Yes! If we understand what we’re working with and how to develop it. Negative evidence is a tool used by many investigative fields; but its definition varies between disciplines. This session defines the concept used by genealogists and historians: contextually suggestive silence. In layman’s language, Mills clearly separates negative evidence from concepts that are often confused with it: negative searches, negative findings, negative arguments, and negative conclusions. Case studies using autosomal and Y-DNA, censuses, church records, death certificates, land deeds and grants, topo maps, and other source types to demonstrate how to recognize contextually suggestive silence and develop it into solutions for situations in which no document explicitly answers our research question. *** This class requires a password and an active webinar membership to attend. On the day of the webinar, obtain the password (located at the top of FamilyTreeWebinars.com when logged in as a member). Then click the Join Webinar link in your confirmation/reminder email, and enter the password when prompted. ***
Fri, September 22 2023: 19:30 UTC
Register for free
Advanced
1:24:26
Places and EthnicitiesBest of ESMMethodology and Skills
Turning Witnesses into Evidence
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.8K views
CC
Turning Witnesses into Evidence
Witnesses are not afterthoughts tacked onto the end of documents. Although they filled a routine role for our ancestors, they are significant informants for us—once we learn how to use those names to develop evidence. This session approaches the topic in two ways: theory and application. It explores record types that offer witnesses, ways in which witnesses were used, situations that affected the choice of witnesses, signals that indicate whether a witness would be important to our research, and methods to apply in our development of the clues they offer. A challenging case study presents an unmarried freedwoman, never named in any census, who died about 1817—and applies key strategies to determine her death and burial sites.
Places and EthnicitiesBest of ESMMethodology and Skills
Turning Witnesses into Evidence
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.8K views
Witnesses are not afterthoughts tacked onto the end of documents. Although they filled a routine role for our ancestors, they are significant informants for us—once we learn how to use those names to develop evidence. This session approaches the topic in two ways: theory and application. It explores record types that offer witnesses, ways in which witnesses were used, situations that affected the choice of witnesses, signals that indicate whether a witness would be important to our research, and methods to apply in our development of the clues they offer. A challenging case study presents an unmarried freedwoman, never named in any census, who died about 1817—and applies key strategies to determine her death and burial sites.
Fri, August 25 2023: 18:00 UTC
Login to register (for webinar members)
Login to register (for webinar members)
Advanced
1:19:08
Best of ESMMethodology and SkillsPlaces and Ethnicities
Problem Solving in the Problem-Riddled Carolina Backcountry
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.6K views
CC
Problem Solving in the Problem-Riddled Carolina Backcountry
The Carolina backcountry is known for its genealogical roadblocks: from social and geographic challenges to record destruction, to the failure to create records in the first place. This session begins by examining the cultural influences that have created the problems—influences we need to understand if we are to develop alternative resources and approaches. Building on this foundation, Mills then explores thirty-two strategies for overcoming research obstacles, using a variety of short case studies and little-known materials to illustrate key points. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Best of ESMMethodology and SkillsPlaces and Ethnicities
Problem Solving in the Problem-Riddled Carolina Backcountry
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.6K views
The Carolina backcountry is known for its genealogical roadblocks: from social and geographic challenges to record destruction, to the failure to create records in the first place. This session begins by examining the cultural influences that have created the problems—influences we need to understand if we are to develop alternative resources and approaches. Building on this foundation, Mills then explores thirty-two strategies for overcoming research obstacles, using a variety of short case studies and little-known materials to illustrate key points. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Fri, July 28 2023: 18:00 UTC
Login to register (for webinar members)
Login to register (for webinar members)
Advanced
1:25:12
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Samuel Witter vs. Samuel Witter: Separating Same Name Men, War of 1812
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.9K views
CC
Samuel Witter vs. Samuel Witter: Separating Same Name Men, War of 1812
Online research today is immensely rewarding. Major genealogical data sites and software perform automatic searches for us and suggest documents bearing the names of people we are pursuing. However, every document we collect presents an identity issue we have to resolve before we can validly use it to build our family tree. This presentation demonstrates why, using three men named Samuel Witter whose descendants have all claimed for him the same War of 1812 service. As Mills separates the three Samuels, she explores the standards that govern our development of evidence, the Congressional laws that must guide our decisions, and the strategies needed to differentiate between men and correctly assign military service. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Samuel Witter vs. Samuel Witter: Separating Same Name Men, War of 1812
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
1.9K views
Online research today is immensely rewarding. Major genealogical data sites and software perform automatic searches for us and suggest documents bearing the names of people we are pursuing. However, every document we collect presents an identity issue we have to resolve before we can validly use it to build our family tree. This presentation demonstrates why, using three men named Samuel Witter whose descendants have all claimed for him the same War of 1812 service. As Mills separates the three Samuels, she explores the standards that govern our development of evidence, the Congressional laws that must guide our decisions, and the strategies needed to differentiate between men and correctly assign military service. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Thu, May 25 2023: 18:00 UTC
Login to register (for webinar members)
Login to register (for webinar members)
Advanced
1:16:38
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Okay, I ‘Got the Neighbors’—Now What Do I Do with Them?!
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
2.2K views
CC
Okay, I ‘Got the Neighbors’—Now What Do I Do with Them?!
We’ve all heard the mantra Get the Neighbors! But exactly how do we use “other people’s” information to solve problems of identity, kinship, and origin for our own ancestors? This session teaches critical skills for building networks around problem ancestors, methods for analyzing and prioritizing associations, and strategies for milking clues from the records those neighbors created. All can be developed into solutions for our toughest research problems.
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Okay, I ‘Got the Neighbors’—Now What Do I Do with Them?!
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
2.2K views
We’ve all heard the mantra Get the Neighbors! But exactly how do we use “other people’s” information to solve problems of identity, kinship, and origin for our own ancestors? This session teaches critical skills for building networks around problem ancestors, methods for analyzing and prioritizing associations, and strategies for milking clues from the records those neighbors created. All can be developed into solutions for our toughest research problems.
Fri, April 28 2023: 18:00 UTC
Login to register (for webinar members)
Login to register (for webinar members)
Advanced
1:11:30
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Elusive Ancestors: Never Too Poor to Trace
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
4.5K views
CC
Elusive Ancestors: Never Too Poor to Trace
Everyone has ancestors who seem to mysteriously appear and then dissolve into the ether, existing nowhere except a family story, a census, or a Bible entry. When deeds, wills, and other standard records fail to yield more information, “too poor to trace!” is a common conclusion—but a wrong one. Many neglected sources include propertyless men, women, and children. This class explores those sources and defines strategies we can use to develop clues, even from records that do not specifically name our ancestors.
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Elusive Ancestors: Never Too Poor to Trace
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
4.5K views
Everyone has ancestors who seem to mysteriously appear and then dissolve into the ether, existing nowhere except a family story, a census, or a Bible entry. When deeds, wills, and other standard records fail to yield more information, “too poor to trace!” is a common conclusion—but a wrong one. Many neglected sources include propertyless men, women, and children. This class explores those sources and defines strategies we can use to develop clues, even from records that do not specifically name our ancestors.
Fri, April 14 2023: 21:00 UTC
Register for free
Advanced
1:27:32
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Margaret’s Baby’s Father & The Lessons He Taught Me
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
2.5K views
CC
Margaret’s Baby’s Father & The Lessons He Taught Me
Illegitimacy. Poverty. Footloose fathers. Record destruction. Name changes. Conflicting data. Forged Bibles. Careless research by predecessors. All these problems can be overcome even when all are combined into one perplexing person. This session presents eight basic principles on which sound research is grounded. For each, it demonstrates how to apply that principle, drawing upon the presenter’s famed case that proved James Ball of Virginia, Tennessee, Mississippi, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Texas, to be the father of a child born to an unmarried mother in 1824 Louisiana. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Margaret’s Baby’s Father & The Lessons He Taught Me
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
2.5K views
Illegitimacy. Poverty. Footloose fathers. Record destruction. Name changes. Conflicting data. Forged Bibles. Careless research by predecessors. All these problems can be overcome even when all are combined into one perplexing person. This session presents eight basic principles on which sound research is grounded. For each, it demonstrates how to apply that principle, drawing upon the presenter’s famed case that proved James Ball of Virginia, Tennessee, Mississippi, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Texas, to be the father of a child born to an unmarried mother in 1824 Louisiana. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Fri, March 24 2023: 18:00 UTC
Login to register (for webinar members)
Login to register (for webinar members)
Advanced
1:19:53
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Smiths & Joneses: Success with Families of Common Name
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
3.0K views
CC
Smiths & Joneses: Success with Families of Common Name
“Identity theft” happens easily with common-name families. This session uses two case studies from two different societies—a Jones family from the Northern U.S. and a Smith family from the South—to demonstrate how to work safely with common-name families. The first ten minutes ground the audience in four problem-solving models. On that foundation, Mills then walks her class through sources and strategies that are often overlooked amid today’s reliance upon database searches, provider hints, and crowd-sourcing. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Best of ESMMethodology and Skills
Smiths & Joneses: Success with Families of Common Name
CC
Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL
3.0K views
“Identity theft” happens easily with common-name families. This session uses two case studies from two different societies—a Jones family from the Northern U.S. and a Smith family from the South—to demonstrate how to work safely with common-name families. The first ten minutes ground the audience in four problem-solving models. On that foundation, Mills then walks her class through sources and strategies that are often overlooked amid today’s reliance upon database searches, provider hints, and crowd-sourcing. *** This class requires an active webinar membership to attend. ***
Fri, February 24 2023: 19:00 UTC
Login to register (for webinar members)
Login to register (for webinar members)